A viologen derivative carrying a benzimidazole group (V‐P‐I ²⁺; viologen–phenylene–imidazole V‐P‐I) can be dimerized in water using cucurbit[8]uril (CB[8]) in the form of a 2:2 complex resulting in a negative shift of the guest pK_a, by more than 1 pH unit, contrasting with the positive pK_a shift usually observed for CB‐based complexes. Whereas 2:2 complex protonation is unclear by NMR, silver cations have been used for probing the accessibility of the imidazole groups of the 2:2 complexes. The protonation capacity of the buried imidazole groups is reduced, suggesting that CB[8] could trigger proton release upon 2:2 complex formation. The addition of CB[8] to a solution containing V‐P‐ I³⁺ indeed released protons as monitored by pH‐metry and visualized by a coloured indicator. This property was used to induce a host/guest swapping, accompanied by a proton transfer, between V‐P‐I ³⁺⋅CB[7] and a CB[8] complex of 1‐methyl‐4‐(4‐pyridyl)pyridinium. The origin of this negative pK_a shift is proposed to stand in an ideal charge state, and in the position of the two pH‐responsive fragments inside the two CB[8] which, alike residues engulfed in proteins, favour the deprotonated form of the guest molecules. Such proton release triggered by a recognition event is reminiscent of several biological processes and may open new avenues toward bioinspired enzyme mimics catalyzing proton transfer or chemical reactions.