UM  > INSTITUTE OF COLLABORATIVE INNOVATION
Residential Collegefalse
Status已發表Published
Gottlob Frege and Gongsun Long in Dialogue: An Exploration of Two Classical Paradoxes from the East and West
Alternative TitleGottlob Frege in Gongsun Long v dialogu: raziskovanje dveh klasičnih paradoksov z Vzhoda in Zahoda
Dolcini, Nevia1,2; Penco, Carlo3
2023-01-10
Source PublicationAsian Studies
ISSN2232-5131
Volume11Issue:1Pages:267-295
Abstract

This work addresses the critical discussion featured in the contemporary literature about two well-known paradoxes belonging to different philosophical traditions, namely Frege’s puzzling claim that “the concept horse is not a concept” and Gongsun Long’s “white horse is not horse”. We first present the source of Frege’s paradox and its different interpretations, which span from plain rejection to critical analysis, to conclude with a more general view of the role of philosophy as a fight against the misunderstandings that come from the different uses of language (a point later developed by the “second” Wittgenstein). We then provide an overview of the ongoing discussions related to the Bai Ma Lun paradox, and we show that its major interpretations include—as in the case of Frege’s paradox—dismissive accounts that regard it as either useless or wrong, as well as attempts to interpret and repair the argument. Resting on our reading of Frege’s paradox as an example of the inescapability of language misunderstandings, we advance a similar line of interpretation for the paradox in the Bai Ma Lun: both the paradoxes, we suggest, can be regarded as different man-ifestations of similar concerns about language, and specifically about the difficulty of referring to concepts via language.

KeywordConcepts Elucidations Gongsun Long Gottlob Frege Language Games Ludwig Wittgenstein Names Paradoxes Philosophy Of Logic
DOI10.4312/as.2023.11.1.267-295
URLView the original
Indexed ByESCI
Language英語English
WOS Research AreaAsian Studies
WOS SubjectAsian Studies
WOS IDWOS:000992570600010
PublisherUNIV LJUBLJANA, CENTRAL LIBRARY, JAMNIKARJEVA 101, P. O. BOX 2995, LJUBLJANA SLO-1111, SLOVENIA
Scopus ID2-s2.0-85146481964
Fulltext Access
Citation statistics
Document TypeJournal article
CollectionINSTITUTE OF COLLABORATIVE INNOVATION
Faculty of Arts and Humanities
DEPARTMENT OF PHILOSOPHY AND RELIGIOUS STUDIES
Corresponding AuthorDolcini, Nevia
Affiliation1.Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies, University of Macao, Macao
2.Center for Cognition and Brain Sciences, University of Macao, Macao
3.Department of Antiquity Philosophy and History, University of Genoa, Italy
First Author AffilicationUniversity of Macau
Corresponding Author AffilicationUniversity of Macau
Recommended Citation
GB/T 7714
Dolcini, Nevia,Penco, Carlo. Gottlob Frege and Gongsun Long in Dialogue: An Exploration of Two Classical Paradoxes from the East and West[J]. Asian Studies, 2023, 11(1), 267-295.
APA Dolcini, Nevia., & Penco, Carlo (2023). Gottlob Frege and Gongsun Long in Dialogue: An Exploration of Two Classical Paradoxes from the East and West. Asian Studies, 11(1), 267-295.
MLA Dolcini, Nevia,et al."Gottlob Frege and Gongsun Long in Dialogue: An Exploration of Two Classical Paradoxes from the East and West".Asian Studies 11.1(2023):267-295.
Files in This Item:
There are no files associated with this item.
Related Services
Recommend this item
Bookmark
Usage statistics
Export to Endnote
Google Scholar
Similar articles in Google Scholar
[Dolcini, Nevia]'s Articles
[Penco, Carlo]'s Articles
Baidu academic
Similar articles in Baidu academic
[Dolcini, Nevia]'s Articles
[Penco, Carlo]'s Articles
Bing Scholar
Similar articles in Bing Scholar
[Dolcini, Nevia]'s Articles
[Penco, Carlo]'s Articles
Terms of Use
No data!
Social Bookmark/Share
All comments (0)
No comment.
 

Items in the repository are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.